From:
Confidence and optimism that we were getting a new blend of players clicking together to…perhaps not challenge for the title but to certainly issue a top-3, “We’re not going anywhere” message to our rivals as we rebuild our side following last season’s drop off.
To:
Wingers with no end product; a midfield with no beef or threat and far too many players, aside from Haaland, who are failing time and time again to contribute in the final third. Oh yeah…and some City fans even questioning Pep Guardiola’s team selection last Sunday, although the man himself didn’t appear to be particularly irritated by the performance in the post-match press conference and, in fact, appeared quite relaxed and pragmatic.
My brief thoughts…
I was transfixed on the game for the first 15+ minutes it was so fast-paced and in that time I thought we started really sharp. Whenever the home side got the ball we were on ‘em quickly and when we had the ball we were zipping it around with pace and confidence; as a clearly ‘up for it’ Villa were chasing us down too.
I think any early warning signs that we were about to fail in our pursuit of getting at least one goal were coming from our left flank in that same spell; with Savinho wasting not one, not two but three good chances to make a good cross and cause the Villa defence more problems than we did. But he wasn’t the only one.
Regular readers might recall that I’m a bit Oscar Bobb fan but he is struggling this season in his 451-league minutes to make much of an impact. He has one assist and no goals.
The aforementioned Savinho continues to frustrate me and many other Blues and he’s starting to remind me a little of Raheem Sterling when the England winger was going through a bad patch - exciting on the eye and then…huffff.
Before we signed Tijjani Reijnders, I was really quite excited and optimistic that we’d signed a class player and his performance against Wolves on the opening day of the season just reinforced those feelings. Since that fine display at Molineux on 16th August he’s managed one further league assist and no additional Premier League goals.
I keep hearing that Phil Foden has returned to the Phil Foden we all love to watch. Really? I will never question his efforts but he’s far from the Phil I know he can be. He has one derby day goal and no assists in the league.
I have to add that Aston Villa defended superbly – one of the best and most determined defending I’ve witnessed in a long time, which tells us that we were at least threatening to score.
It's enough to make you wonder how we managed to go nine games unbeaten in all competitions up to last weekend but then again, we have Gianluigi Donnnarumma, a far more stable defence than last season and a certain Mr Haaland.
Well, that’s all fairly grim sounding after a good September and October. Is a League Cup game away at a Championship side a good match to get it out of our collective systems; particularly the players? I say, “No, not really”.
However, it does give us some room to rest and rotate a little and a full week before our next league fixture for Pep to analyse just how the hell we lost another game at Villa Park; our fourth-straight season without a win there in the Prem. In addition, our manager might want to try ‘n’ explore why our other, highly talented players just aren’t contributing nearly enough in the final third; weather that’s with final passes / crosses or goals themselves.
![]() |
| Swansea.com Stadium |
Predicted line-up, subs and outcome:
(Number correct from the starting line-up in the last game: 8/11).
A very fluid 4-1-4-1 / 4-5-1 / 4-3-3 (occasional 3-6-1):
__________________Marmoush____________________
Doku_____________________________________Cherki
_________Silva(C)_________________Lewis__________
___________________Gonzalez____________________
O’Reilly___________________________________Nunes
____________Ake________________Stones_________
____________________Trafford____________________
Subs: Donnarumma, Ait-Nouri, Dias, Kovacic, Foden, Mukasa, Reijnders, Bobb and Savinho.
James takes the gloves for this competition.
My back-4, occasional 3, prediction is Nico-O-, Nathan, John and Matheus.
Nigo-G- starts this one in my opinion, following a knock and then substitute appearance last Sunday.
Ahead of our defensive midfield I’m going for Jeremy, Bernardo, Rico and Rayan-C-.
Omar, making only his fifth appearance of the season having spent around 7 weeks out with a knee injury, leads our attack.
I’m going to stick with that predicted 11, despite having second thoughts about whether it’s still too early for Rayan Cherki to start a game. We could see Phil Foden start again and move over to the right flank instead.
Gigi moves to the bench as reserve keeper; Rayan-A- and Ruben provide defensive cover from the side. Mateo, Phil, Divine and Tijjani make up four midfielders on the bench, while Oscar and Savinho provide wing options from ‘the 9’.
Notable absences:
- Marcus Bettinelli – Not selected.
- Stefan Ortega – Not selected.
- Abdukodir Khusanov – On 24th October, Pep said of Khusanov, “I think he's close to coming back, but still, I think he's not ready. He had an injury in a dangerous, dangerous position in his body”.
- Josko Gvardiol – Not selected / rested.
- Kalvin Phillips – Not selected.
- Rodri – Remains out with a hamstring injury. Unknown return date but we were informed on 28th October that he was back in light / partial training with his teammates.
- Erling Haaland – Not selected / rested.
Do I agree with Pep’s (predicted) line-up?
Yeah, looks good.
I’m pleased that we’ll have the opportunity to rest some players who have played a lot of minutes already this season and, if I’m correct, I’m looking forward to seeing how Lewis, Cherki and Marmoush perform in particular.
Result?
Our host couldn’t be more in the middle of their division if they tried. They sit right in the centre of their table having won 4, drawn 4 and lost 4; scoring 12 and conceding 12 also. Wow.
No consistency appears to be the monkey on their back at the moment, with a last 6 in the league looking like this: D W L D L W.
I think we’ll find that our hosts will be stubborn and we’ll have to work hard to break ‘em down. However, with some players keen to make their mark after limited game time and with the quality we have in that predicted line-up, I’m going for a Manchester City win.
Last season’s, corresponding pre-match prediction and result:
Prediction: N/A
Result: N/A
Expected weather conditions during the game: Dry but chilly. It might show 10C on the thermometer but the forecasted “feels like” is closer to 8C in the stiff, westerly breeze. 🍵🥧🧥🧣🧤🍺⚽
![]() |
| Solidarity |









