Sunday, 4 October 2020

I wish some City fans would get a grip!

With an international break now upon us, I thought I’d ‘sign off’, for the time being, with a little piece about a ‘reality check’.

Astonishing whilst at the same time…

…not overly surprising, I suppose.

Of course, it’s inevitable that after seasons of BIG spending, seeing football stars aplenty and ever improving managers coming through our door; expectation levels will rise. But what’s been a little shocking for me over the last few years, is the sheer number of City fans - a lot of whom have been going longer than I have, which is since the mid-1980s and who have, therefore, seen far more dross and bad times than I have - who get so upset when we don’t win or win BIG! Fans in their mid-to-late 50s & 60s who, I believe, should know better than to start getting all ‘Billy Big Biscuits’ and having occasional tantrums when things don’t go our way.

I’m reminded about a game I watched in my local 2 or 3 seasons back when we just about managed a draw away at Crystal Palace. It was all that one, long-standing City fan, then in his late 60s, could stand; as he ranted and whinged on and on for ages about how poor we were. That was a real stand-out moment for me and it left me feeling really disappointed with my fellow Blue; more so than the “dropped” 2 points.

Me too?

Of course, I now expect more from our club, manager and team that has so much talent in it and yeah; I still get disappointed when we lose, which I thought was a little too often last season.

In fact, last Sunday’s 2-5 home defeat to Leicester City still hurt a couple of days later and I found it quite difficult to bring myself round to writing a pre-Burnley post.

But after watching some truly terrible football as a City supporter for so many years, where I’ve suffered SO many relegations right down to the 3rd tier of professional English football; I like to think that I still have a firm grip on reality as well as, in fact, still stepping back from time to time in disbelief about the many, many trophies we’ve won and the many, many records we’ve broken…not forgetting the jaw-dropping football I’ve had the privilege to watch in recent seasons.

And now?

Good grief! I’ve both heard and read some crap from some City fans in recent days.

It started at half time v Leicester on my local radio station where, apparently, City fans had been contacting the station via social media towards the end of the first half with comments like, Kyle Walker and, get this, Raheem Sterling were too old / past it and we should be moved on! This is the game where 33-year old Jamie Vardy ripped us to shreds and scored a hat-trick…

Then, a couple of days later, the same bloke who was nearly crying post-Crystal Palace years earlier, passed me in the street and proclaimed that we were, “Bloody crap”, referring to the Leicester game, presumably.

Then, after yesterday’s brilliant game and away point - that’s…an away point – I went from TV to a national radio station for a short time to find a queue of City-fan-callers, all of which were practically in meltdown! And even though I was nodding in agreement with some of the words one caller was straining herself to get out as quickly as she could, it was the sheer level of panic and anxiety in her voice that had me shaking my head in disbelief. The next fella was shouting so loud in anger I could only pick out every other word…

3 games in with a game in hand over most! That’s…THREE GAMES IN!

Has it really come to this - are “we” now that used to watching top-class football from Manchester City and winning so much that when we don’t win or, indeed, don’t batter teams off the park; that some Blues think that’s ‘the end of us’ as a competing football club? That’s what it sounds like when I’m listing to some of our fans having a nervous breakdown or reading their well-over-the-top comments.

Are there any causes for concern?

Yeah, of course, not everything's right with us at the moment and I too wrote a piece after the Leicester defeat, where I highlighted some issues that I thought we had and still do.

·         I honestly can’t remember the last time we had a decent left-back / left-wing back for a sustained period of time. I wasn’t an Aleks Kolarov fan whatsoever so I’m thinking, Andy Hinchliffe? Neil Pointon? No? Bobby McDonald then? Perhaps someone with a better memory than me could, perhaps, fill in some gaps or bring me more up-to-date than Neil Pointon. Years…YEARS I’ve been going on about the need for a decent Zabaleta-like player on the left-hand flank of the defence and it’s no different today. I actually thought, stupidly, and for a reasonable time at Elland Road yesterday, that Benjamin Mendy was having a decent game. But then he just reverted to his usual standards as the game progressed in the second half. So yeah…I agree with the ranting woman on national radio that we DO need to sign a left-sided defender as soon as possible.

·         Do we need a striker, which was something the same caller was-also in a rage about? Well, regular readers might recall (I don’t think I’ve mentioned it for some time) that I’ve always believed that, despite the amount of goals our team has in it from the midfield & wing departments, most ‘top clubs’ in the world who are fighting in 4 competitions over 60+ games-a-season should be running with 3 top-quality strikers. That, at least, also gives you more of an option in games to change something significantly that might not-otherwise be working, rather than just tinkering / changing personnel ‘like for like’. And the signs have been shining brightly at us for a number of seasons, now; that Sergio Aguero was always going to be seeing more of the treatment room as the seasons passed. Indeed, Gabriel Jesus sees his own fair share of the medical staff; with a decent amount of ‘time out’ himself. It’s great to see Liam Delap step up and there’s a decent argument that we’ve perhaps not, in this short season so far, shown quite enough faith in the 17-year old. So yeah, I see this as another failing in us not reacting to an obvious situation; similar in how we failed to replace Vincent Kompany quick enough. But I will admit, I say all of that knowing that our owners must have had one eye on that FIFA mess and the possible sanctions we could have faced if we’d have lost our appeal.

·         And yep, we are already falling behind in the league even at this early stage. It’s generally considered that you can’t lose more than 4 games and that you shouldn’t draw too many others in a season if you want to stand a chance of wining the league and, so, I sort of get some City fans flapping a little when they see, P3 W1 D1 L1. But flippin’ ‘eck! We’ve had SO many key players out with injury or Covid-19 related and I honestly believe that, perhaps Liverpool aside; if we’d have played that well and with that level of intensity as we did yesterday against ANY other league side, we’d have won handsomely. A LOT of credit has to go to Leeds United and Marcelo Bielsa!

We’ve just signed a flippin’ world-class central defender to add to Aymeric Laporte and Nathan Ake and, following the international break, we’re likely to see Gabriel Jesus return with Sergio not far behind him, fingers crossed.

Yeah, I don’t like to see us this many points behind so many in-form & improved teams and yes-definitely; if we don’t restart well after the international break and both maintain some form and find a way to beat teams who appear to ‘have the makings of us’ now, then I can easily see us not regaining the Premier League trophy. That’ll hurt a little and I might have some questions about where we go from there in order to try ‘n’ get back on track.

But flippin’ ‘eck! I’m not ready to pack it all in just like, it increasingly seems, quite a few other Blues are!


 

Friday, 2 October 2020

Apprentice versus the Master?

I’m not sure that is the case but, at the very least, Pep Guardiola does put tomorrow’s more-senior opposite number, Marcelo Bielsa, on a very high pedestal.

v Leeds United

Elland Road
Predicted line-up, subs and outcome:

(Number correct from the starting line-up in the last game: A really poor 5/11 in the League Cup last Wednesday night; as Pep sprung several surprises in a much-stronger-than-expected line-up).

Fluid 4-1-5-0 / 4-6-0 / 3-7-0:

______________________________________________

___________________Sterling____________________

 

__Torres______________________________Mahrez__

 

___________De Bruyne______Foden_______________

 

_________________Fernandinho__________________

Mendy___________________________________Walker

 

____________Laporte_________Dias_______________

 

 

___________________Ederson____________________

Subs: Steffen, Ake, Garcia, Rodri, Doyle, Silva, Delap (all nice-short surnames there! 😊).

Ederson continues the pass the parcel and reclaims the gloves for this league game.

Left-wing back should be Benjamin; right-wing back should be well-used-so-far, Kyle. Will they? Won’t they? I’m going…yes, they will. Aymeric & new-singing Ruben to start & partner in the middle of the defence. Exciting…

I think we’ll only see one defensive midfielder for this clash and I’m going for Fernandinho to be that fella.

A sort of…5, in a way, ahead of the Brazilian – an exciting combination of Kevin, Phil, Ferran, Riyad & Raheem.

Zack is back as reserve stopper; Nathan & Eric the defensive replacement options from the side. Rodders, Tommy, Bernardo & Liam likely to provide the midfield / wing / attacking choice-replacements from ‘the 7’.

Notable absences:

-       Joao Cancelo – Out until about mid-October with a foot injury.

-       Oleksandr Zinchenko – Having made an unexpected and brief appearance recently on the bench v Leicester; the young Ukrainian was then-apparently injured in training. I just wonder, though, Nicolas Otamendi-style, whether Oleksandr is being given time to ponder / ‘plan for’ a move away; as we continue to be linked with Argentine Nicolas Tagliafico (love that surname), from Ajax.

-       Ilkay Gundogan – The good news is that he’s re-joined the squad after Covid-19 isolation. However, he is yet to train with his teammates and the German international will now use the international break to try 'n' get himself up to speed.

-       Gabriel Jesus – Out until at least mid-October with a muscular injury.

-       Sergio Aguero – Training alone / recovering slowly from knee surgery. Expected to return around early-to-mid November.

Do I agree with Pep’s (predicted) line-up?

If Mendy & Mahrez perform, I’m quite excited with that predicted line-up & formation. As I’ve said, I’m really looking forward to seeing the centre-back partnership, should that happen tomorrow.

Result? If this game goes ahead (see weather forecast below), then I’m REALLY looking forward to this game!

And do you know what? If I’m right about ‘the 11’ etc. and the team in general performs well; I’ve got a good feeling about this one in-that…not only do I think we’ll win but I also think we’ll get a few goals and keep a clean sheet! 3 points to 'the Blues' (or more-likely the players dressed in black).

Last season’s, corresponding pre-match prediction and result…

Prediction: N/A

Result: N/A

Expected weather conditions during the game: Absolutely awful! So bad is the forecast of such a long period of heavy rain both before & during the game, I have wondered for a brief time whether the game will-actually go ahead! That, of course, all depends on what the Elland Road pitch is like drainage-wise…and I just haven’t a clue. A stiff, north-easterly wind doesn’t help either and with temperatures no higher than 13C, it’ll feel more like 9 or 10 for the players & all-round staff, I’m sure. Enough for new-signing Ruben Dias to get back on a plane to warmer climes of Portugal? Probably not - he’s already trained in torrential, short-sharp showers in Manchester since his arrival. But Marcelo Bielsa had better make doubly-sure that he has his ‘sitting bucket’ the right-way-round on Saturday…

Wednesday, 30 September 2020

League, cup, league, cup…

…is the marching sound of these strange times at the moment; as alternate competitions early on in the season continue to fly at us at a fair ol’ rate of knots.

With changes in ‘the 11’ inevitable, it’s not exactly a game to get that last, disastrous result ‘out of our system’. But a victory over a Premier League side and progression to the 5th round of the League Cup might just act as a small dose of tonic before we march on back into league action away at Leeds United on Saturday.

v Burnley

Turf Moor
Predicted line-up, subs and outcome:

(Number correct from the starting line-up in the last game: 9/11).

Fluid 4-1-4-1 / 4-5-1 / 4-3-3:

_____________________Delap_____________________

 

 

___Foden______________________________Torres___

 

_____________Doyle__________Palmer_____________

 

__________________Fernandinho__________________

Zinchenko_________________________________Garcia

 

____________Laporte_________Harwood-Bellis______

 

 

_____________________Steffen____________________

Subs: Carson, Mendy, Ake, Rodri, De Bruyne, Sterling, Mahrez.

It seems like ‘pass the parcel’ at the moment - Zack gets handed back the gloves for this one.

Having been given an early, unexpected place on the bench last Sunday; Oleksandr should return from muscular injury to make his first season start at left-wing. SURELY Pep has to give Kyle Walker a rest now before our weekend league fixture and if so, I can only think that Eric will be asked to both ‘go again’ and cover in that position, as Guardiola doesn’t appear to be dipping into the EDS for right-wing backs in such circumstances. I don’t think there’s much doubt that Taylor will get another start in this competition in the middle of the defence and I suspect that we might see Aymeric get his first start of the season, following Covid-19 isolation, to partner the 18-year old Stockport lad.

Having been withdrawn as early as 51 minutes last Sunday, I’m going for Fernandinho to ‘get the nod’ as our one & only defensive midfielder.

Ahead of the Brazilian, a couple of lads whose combined age is just 36 – Tommy and possibly making his first-team debut, is Wythenshawe born Cole. Phil could well be asked to start another game, which is likely to be a role that sees him coming in from the left wing with, surely, Ferran starting on the attacking right.

Liam to be the recipient of some considerable creativity from the midfield / wing departments.

Scott gets his second ‘bench spot’ in a week; Benjamin & Nathan make up the only defensive change-option from the side. Rodders, Kevin, Raheem & Riyad are the midfield & wing choices from ‘the 7’.

Notable absences:

-       Ederson – Not selected / rested.

-       Joao Cancelo – Out until about mid-October with a foot injury.

-       Kyle Walker – Not selected / rested / protected.

-       John Stones – I’m just not sure. The last time I heard he was deemed as not fit enough to be in the [last] match-day squad. Does that mean that he wasn’t really fit enough when he faced Wolves the other week? I don’t get it…

-       Bernardo Silva – Out until about mid-October with a quadriceps strain.

-       Ilkay Gundogan – In Covid-19 isolation up to and including 30.09.2020, so this should be the last game he’ll be missing for, in relation to the Coronavirus at least. However, as was the case with Laporte, Ilkay may-then-have-to take time to get his fitness levels up, so he may-not-necessarily be available for Saturday’s game.

-       Gabriel Jesus – Out until at least mid-October with a muscular injury.

-       Sergio Aguero – Training alone / recovering slowly from knee surgery. Expected to return around early-to-mid November.

Do I agree with Pep’s (predicted) line-up?

Well, it’s not ideal in some ways but I’d have to say, yes.

Foden is most-definitely more effective when-playing more centrally, in my opinion, and although Garcia has covered at right-wing back before; don’t be expecting lung-busting runs up & down the wing, Kyle style, to support the attacking play & defend in equal measures.

As for the other flank, we can only hope that Oleksandr is fit enough to play at least 60 minutes in his first game back, should he start of course.

I think it’s definitely right to give Tommy Doyle & Ferran Torres staring places in this fixture and to give Cole Palmer his debut too.

Result? It’s really hard to call this one.

If Sean Dyche decides to put out a strong side containing mostly ‘first 11s’, then I can see us struggling a little with that young and, in some ways, adaptive team.

If our hosting manager deploys a ‘mixed bag’ or even a very-much-weakened side and our guys put on a good display – particularly from Ferran, Phil & Liam - then I can see us winning this encounter in normal time.

So...I’m ‘fence sitting’. I’m going for a draw after 90 minutes and, therefore, it’s anyone’s penalty shoot-out to win which, of course, I’m just not gonna attempt to predict.

Another League Cup game I’m not going to be able to watch for more reasons than one… ☹

Last season’s, corresponding pre-match prediction and result…

Prediction: N/A

Result: N/A

Expected weather conditions during the game: Wet, breezy & chilly. Light rain continues during the match; following all-day rain that’s gonna leave a soggy pitch for sure. 12C is the late September temperature for this fixture.

Monday, 28 September 2020

Sifting through the mess…

I rarely do a post-match posting but whether it’s for personal therapy or not, how can I possibly not make comment after something like that – our heaviest home defeat in 17 years?!

Where to begin…

May-as-well, at least, start with some player analysis and, therefore, start at the back.

Ederson:

Can’t fault him for anything. In fact, if memory serves, he was very close to most of the balls that flew past him – he just didn’t quite have the reach.

Benjamin Mendy:

Bloody awful again! I think I recall him-making one, neat slide pass [to Foden I think it was] but other than that, his decision-making is non-existent; his injuries have caused his most-potent weapon, his pace, to be reduce by at least 25% and other than that, he’s a ‘one-trick pony’ in terms of getting the ball to the by-line and then ‘power-slapping’ it towards the opposition box; in a ‘hit & hope’ fashion. No surprise to me whatsoever that he bundled over a Leicester player to give away 1 of 3 penalties – he’s little more than a clumsy oaf who just can’t defend…and he’s supposed to be a wing-back! The Manchester Evening News gave him 3/10…

Nathan Ake:

He must surely be thinking, following his move from relegated Bournemouth, Out of the frying pan and into the fire. Did nothing wrong, from what I can recall, and got his debut goal to make it 2-4. I think, though, that once Ruben Dias arrives and settles in AND we get Laporte up back up to speed; if we DON’T also sign a new left-wing back before the “summer” transfer window shuts; then I’d like to see him at least shuffle over to that position. I know he’s not the kind of left-back that ‘gets up & down the pitch’ but at least he can flippin’ defend a bit.

Eric Garcia:

The irony! The only defender who has expressed a desire to leave the club and, just like he did against Lyon, had a stand-out performance at the back. I don’t even blame him for giving away 1 of 3 penalties; where as 2 were down-right naïve by his colleagues, his was simply a case of being done by a clever-thinking Vardy. That one was, for me though, a soft penalty and I was venting my disapproval at the TV as soon as the England forward went down.

Kyle Walker:

Again, apart from a case of ‘should have known better’ – and what I mean was just let the flippin’ attacking player go in those circumstances, as the Leicester player still had Ederson to beat from a narrowing angle and we had another defender bombing in also – he probably just about edged out Garcia as-being our best “defender”. And when HE got forward, it looked more promising; in that something would come of it in the opposition’s box. Apart from giving the penalty away, I can’t really fault him.

This is where I think it gets a little yuckier though…

Rodri & Fernandinho:

I’ve put ‘em together because…I actually don’t think either of them had a particularly BAD game and if I was to separate them, I’d say Fernandinho had the slightly better of the two. But, for me, what appeared to work so very well at Wolves last Monday - creating an extra defensive shield and allowing other players to ‘run riot’ - not only just didn’t work yesterday but I think it was largely our undoing. There was no ‘attacking thrust’ or urgency through the middle. Instead, after our opening goal it was all fairly slow, side-passing, which largely allowed the opposition to just ‘sit & watch’ our metronome passing before bursting out and causing damage to us. I don’t know if you saw the post-match talk on Sky Sports but Micah Richards was particularly scathing of Rodri; basically, saying that all he was contributing was slow & short side passes. Pretty much what I’ve just said really – metronome.

Phil Foden:

I don’t know whether, as my eyes slowly deteriorate with age, I need to consider getting a larger television but I was struggle for a long, long time to see him on the pitch. He was, of course, operating in a left-hand-side-attack role but Leicester’s 5-man defence simply smothered the young lad. Nothing more to say really – he was completely ineffective out there yesterday and was duly substituted.

Kevin De Bruyne:

What a surprise – our best player on the pitch! Even then, though, for all his hard work once again, where he was popping up all over the place probing the Foxes’ defence; he was getting little joy and that same, local news outlet could “only” manage to give him a 7.

Riyad Mahrez:

…and I say his name in my head with a sigh. Regular readers will know my firm opinions of the Algerian winger – he’s either practically unplayable when he’s ‘on it’ and because he’s got skill & tricks aplenty…but then he has games where he looks like he’s never had a ball at his feet before; where nothing seems to come off for him and before he vanishes completely out of the game. Yesterday’s performance was a PERFECT example of that – a WONDERFUL strike on / around 4-minutes but then…nothing. I swear that for a good while after his goal he was walking around with an expression on his face that said, Look at me, look at me! I’ve scored a great goal against the team a I used to play for! After a while, though, that facial expression turned to a heavy frown; as nothing he touched came off. A perfect Mahrez display in so many ways!

Raheem Sterling:

Quiet game, snuffed out. Sometimes I’ve seen him have decent games when asked to cover in a central striker role…but not often. This one certainly didn’t work but I can’t bring myself to blame him in this one.

I’m a bit reluctant to go beyond the ‘starting 11’ but I will say a little bit…

I thought seeing the imposing figure of Liam Delap come on the was a refreshing sight and he got a header in quite excellently, which skimmed the top of the crossbar not long after coming on. Other than that, though, just like they did with the rest of our players; he was largely snuffed out by Leicester.

And as for Ferran Torres, I just don’t think that the situation has been right in both Premier League matches for him to come on and shine…and, so I’m led to believe, he was asked to play an unfamiliar narrow role in our cup win over Bournemouth? Either way, he’ll have better opportunities to show us & all what he can do. Personally, though, I’d like to see him on his preferred right with Sterling on the left wing whenever we get all our personnel back…

Pep:


Peed me off a bit, I have to be honest.

Now, I’m not sure if you’ll believe me but Mr Guardiola gets paid FAR more than I do. No? Okay.

But I’m sat on my settee with my senses slightly effected by a few beers while Pep, presumably sober, had a far closer view than I had; and I could see, quite clearly, that despite largely controlling the ball with huge amounts of possession in the first half, Leicester’s probing, break-away attacks were getting more and more dangerous as time ‘ticked on’. And, just as Micah was saying afterwards, that plodding, side-passing was doing nothing to either threaten the visitors nor supress those increasing bursts of threat. WHY, then, did Pep do nothing to change it?!

Foden was doing nothing out on the left so bring him inside, I was screaming in my head, to inject some dynamic pace in the middle to help Rodders & Fern; put Raheem in his preferred left-side role and give the overloaded Leicester defence no-one specific to focus on. I reckon that if we’d have done that before they scored their equaliser, we’d have got around / behind them more with Phil & Kevin then-running onto balls from deep. It might not have worked but, before we made any subs, something like that would have been worth a flippin’ try at least!

It sometimes baffles me that for such a great manager – and he is – when it’s not going to plan, he looks so deep in thought, at times, that I swear he’s already thinking how he can fix it for the next game rather than sorting it there & then. I know that sounds mad, but…

We’ll get better…won’t we?

We won’t see too many 2-5s again this season and we were missing key players who can - and would have - made a difference, I'm sure. But you won’t find too many non-City fans feeling sorry for us with our injury plight and I don’t think we should either, with the vast amounts of money we’ve spent.

This Ruben fella looks decent and with him coming in, Aymeric returning very soon and likely to partner the Frenchman, then-perhaps Nathan ‘shuffling over’ and with Joao Cancelo not THAT far off a return himself; things will settle down at the back. But I still hope & pray that we sign a flippin’-good left-wing back before the current window slams shut.

However, Pep has got to find that devastating pace again that we’ve seen so many times – that quick-passing, dynamic blitz that’s left us open-mouthed in awe.

I know the current situation isn’t ideal and that it hasn’t exactly been the best pre-season preparation time but, of course, that goes for the all the other sides too.

And I acknowledge also that there have been some CRAZY scores in the league so far already, which includes yesterday’s disaster-day at the office for us.

But if we’re not careful, we’re gonna see another league campaign, at least, slip from our grasp. The pattern from last season is already starting to show itself once again (in all comps) – W W L…